Moving in Quebec: When Is a Moving Company Liable?

A scratched dresser, a missing box, a late delivery: who pays? In Quebec, a mover is in principle liable for the belongings it carries, from the moment it takes charge of them until delivery. The law does, however, allow it to avoid liability in a few specific situations, provided it can prove them. Here is when a mover is liable, when it is not, and what to do if something goes wrong.

The key principle

  • The mover is liable for the carriage: it must deliver your belongings to their destination and make good any harm resulting from the carriage (art. 2049 of the Civil Code of Québec).
  • No automatic exemption: it is up to the mover to prove that a cause recognized by law explains the problem. A “not responsible” clause or a deductible imposed on the consumer is not permitted.

To reduce risks from the start, see our residential moving and packing and unpacking service.

The 3 situations where liability may be ruled out

1

Superior force

An unforeseeable and irresistible event, outside the mover’s control, that causes the damage, loss or delay.

Example: the authorities suddenly close the highway after a disaster, and the delivery cannot take place on the scheduled day.

2

Inherent defect of the item

A defect that already existed in the item and that, on its own, explains the damage despite normal handling.

Example: a table leg that was already cracked and glued gives way even though the table is carried with care.

3

The customer’s fault

Where legally applicable: if the customer caused or worsened the damage, their share of responsibility may reduce or rule out the mover’s liability.

Example: dishes packed by the customer, with no paper or padding, break inside an undamaged box.

The Civil Code also mentions “normal shrinkage”, meaning the natural loss of weight or volume of certain goods during carriage. It rarely applies to a residential move.

What a mover’s liability covers

The carrier’s liability covers the period from the moment it takes charge of your belongings until delivery. In practice, the company is responsible, among other things, for:

  • Damage caused by handling, packing done by its own crew, poor securing in the truck or a fall.
  • Losses: a misplaced box, a forgotten piece of furniture, a missing part after disassembly by the crew.
  • Delivery delays, unless it proves superior force.

You generally do not have to prove negligence: the fact that an item arrived damaged, or did not arrive, is in principle enough to engage the mover’s liability.

The conditions for each exemption

In each case, the burden of proof is on the mover. A court assesses the situation on its facts.

Superior force: an unforeseeable and irresistible event

Both conditions must be met: the event could not have been foreseen and it was impossible to overcome (art. 1470 C.C.Q.).

  • May be invoked: a sudden road closure ordered by the authorities, a natural disaster of exceptional scale.
  • Generally not accepted: heavy traffic, a storm forecast several days ahead, a poorly maintained truck that breaks down, an understaffed crew.

Inherent defect: a flaw already present in the item

This is a weakness specific to the item: a joint already coming apart, particleboard swollen by humidity, glass already cracked. The mover must show that this defect, and not its handling, explains the damage. If the crew dropped the item or did not protect it properly, inherent defect does not apply.

Point out fragile, antique or previously repaired furniture in advance: the crew can adapt the protection, and the item’s condition will be known to everyone.

Customer’s fault: under the general rules

This situation is not among the exemptions listed in article 2049. It falls under the general rules: a person who contributed to the harm bears part of it (art. 1478 C.C.Q.). Depending on the facts, it may reduce or, more rarely, rule out the mover’s liability. Possible examples:

  • Boxes packed by the customer without enough protection, damaged inside while the carton is intact.
  • A high-value or very fragile item that was not declared before departure.
  • Incorrect information about access, dimensions or the contents of a piece of furniture.

Precautions before moving day

  • Detailed written contract kept on file
  • Dated photos of furniture and rooms
  • Inventory of numbered boxes
  • Fragile or valuable items declared in writing
  • Valuables and documents kept with you
  • Existing defects noted before loading

When the mover remains liable

  • Exclusion clause in the contract: a merchant cannot exempt itself from the consequences of its own act or that of its employees (s. 10 of the Consumer Protection Act).
  • Imposed deductible: the Office de la protection du consommateur points out that a company cannot limit its liability by imposing a deductible on the consumer.
  • Packing done by the crew: if the movers packed the item, insufficient packing is their responsibility.
  • Securing or handling: a poorly strapped piece of furniture that slides in the truck is neither superior force nor an inherent defect.
  • Scheduling delays: a delay caused by planning or by another job does not exempt the mover.

Packing and protection

What you pack. Use sturdy boxes, paper or towels around fragile items, and write “Fragile” and the room on each box. Our little packing tips will guide you.

What the crew protects. Bon Avenir movers protect furniture with blankets and strap it in the truck. For a piano or a pool table, specialized handling is planned.

Items to keep with you. Jewellery, cash, important documents and medication are best kept with you. See also what movers don’t transport.

What to do if a piece of furniture is damaged?

  1. Report it on the spot: tell the crew leader and, if possible, have it noted on the delivery document.
  2. Take photos of the item, the packing and the box, and throw nothing away.
  3. Send a written notice to the company within 60 days of delivery, describing the damage and your request.
  4. Try to reach an agreement: repair, replacement or compensation.
  5. If no agreement: a formal demand letter, then, if needed, the Small Claims Division for claims of $15,000 or less.

To learn more, read what to do if movers damage your belongings.

Evidence to keep and claim deadlines

  • Keep: contract, quote, invoices, before and after photos, inventory, written exchanges, and a repair estimate or proof of the item’s value.
  • 60-day notice: an action against a carrier can only proceed if a written notice of claim was given within 60 days of delivery, whether or not the loss is apparent (art. 2050 C.C.Q.).
  • Item never delivered: notice must be given within nine months of the date of shipment.
  • Exception: no notice is needed if the lawsuit is filed within that same period.
  • Prescription: the time limit to sue starts running on delivery, or on the date the item should have been delivered. Don’t wait: act as soon as possible.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to prove the movers were negligent?

Generally, no. It is usually enough to show that the item was damaged or lost during the move. It is then up to the mover to prove a cause of exemption recognized by law.

Does the 60-day deadline apply to damage discovered later?

Yes. The Civil Code states that written notice must be given within 60 days of delivery, whether or not the loss is apparent. Open your boxes and inspect your furniture soon after the move.

Are boxes I packed myself covered?

The mover remains responsible for the carriage. However, if the carton is intact but the contents broke for lack of padding, it could argue that the packing was insufficient. To avoid that debate, you can entrust fragile items to our packing service.

Where can I store my belongings if the new home isn’t ready?

A gap between two homes can be planned ahead with temporary storage, such as our Bon Cube storage. Include your dates in a free quote.

Sources: LégisQuébec – Civil Code of Québec (arts. 1470, 1478, 2034, 2040, 2049 and 2050); LégisQuébec – Consumer Protection Act (s. 10); Office de la protection du consommateur – reminders before moving season, 2025 (in French); Éducaloi – When a move goes wrong (in French). This article provides general information and is not legal advice.

More articles in: Moving advice

fleche